Jump to content
Forum | Bia2.com
irannostalgia

Comments on new iranian releases

Recommended Posts

Noooo!!! :eek_wft: :eek_wft:

 

well this makes one wonder has this guy ever written a song himself???

 

 

http://shadmehrsong.mihanblog.com/More-46.ASPX

 

My friend i dont need u to give me a list of what he has composed! i know them!

as far as we found out even couple of his songs in iran were infact rip offs! also with Greek origins! So, u do the math!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Noooo!!! :eek_wft: :eek_wft:

 

well this makes one wonder has this guy ever written a song himself???

 

 

http://shadmehrsong.mihanblog.com/More-46.ASPX

 

My friend i dont need u to give me a list of what he has composed! i know them!

as far as we found out even couple of his songs in iran were infact rip offs! also with Greek origins! So, u do the math!

 

are u referring to "Jaddeh"? i know that... But how does that prove ALL the songs to be ripoffs?! u are exaggerating

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
He is working more with the DISCO-FUNK lately, I like the experiment but I liked "Residi" much better as a result than this! Kheili shol o vele! Btw I've been tipped off that "Residi" is in fact a Godiva original! I have yet not found which song it is!

 

Pourya, I have listened to all of Godiva's albums (namely: Godiva, Call Me Under 666, Destruction), and there was NO song that sounded like Shadmehr's Residi. I listened to all of their songs again and again, but I didnt find any original version of Residi in them ! so... i guess ur sources are lying to u

 

Thanks for your info, we'll see what others in work might find.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Noooo!!! :eek_wft: :eek_wft:

 

well this makes one wonder has this guy ever written a song himself???

 

 

http://shadmehrsong.mihanblog.com/More-46.ASPX

 

My friend i dont need u to give me a list of what he has composed! i know them!

as far as we found out even couple of his songs in iran were infact rip offs! also with Greek origins! So, u do the math!

 

are u referring to "Jaddeh"? i know that... But how does that prove ALL the songs to be ripoffs?! u are exaggerating

 

What you are giving a link to is based on Shadmehr's own declaration of him composing the songs, and record shows that his own declarations are not much to count on. So raising the question Ahmad has done is completely justified.

 

A coincidence, when I reviewed POPCORN a certain DJ Nima from canada contacted me and thought I was unfair giving him a low rating in ethical adherence based on the song POPCORN, since the rest was Shadmehr's own! Later the opposite was proved and songs that in fact were not composed by Shadmehr!

 

So its a justified question to ask and wonder as long as things seem to be heading the same direction!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Noooo!!! :eek_wft: :eek_wft:

 

well this makes one wonder has this guy ever written a song himself???

 

 

http://shadmehrsong.mihanblog.com/More-46.ASPX

 

My friend i dont need u to give me a list of what he has composed! i know them!

as far as we found out even couple of his songs in iran were infact rip offs! also with Greek origins! So, u do the math!

 

are u referring to "Jaddeh"? i know that... But how does that prove ALL the songs to be ripoffs?! u are exaggerating

 

What you are giving a link to is based on Shadmehr's own declaration of him composing the songs, and record shows that his own declarations are not much to count on. So raising the question Ahmad has done is completely justified.

 

A coincidence, when I reviewed POPCORN a certain DJ Nima from canada contacted me and thought I was unfair giving him a low rating in ethical adherence based on the song POPCORN, since the rest was Shadmehr's own! Later the opposite was proved and songs that in fact were not composed by Shadmehr!

 

So its a justified question to ask and wonder as long as things seem to be heading the same direction!

 

 

exactly! in any other case I'd say its they're own compistion until proven otherwise!

but in shadmehr's case i think its a rip off unless proven otherwise :p all the songs after his departure from iran atleast !!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What you are giving a link to is based on Shadmehr's own declaration of him composing the songs, and record shows that his own declarations are not much to count on.

 

So you mean , for example, even Mahasti's album (Az Khoda Khasteh) was not composed by Shadmehr himself?!! lol cmon man! i'll give u $1000 for any song that is a "rip off" on that album. I guess Shadmehr uses greek songs when it comes to his own work (as he has said himself, he likes greek and irish melodies) - btw, i dont support the fact that he declares himself as the composer of those greek-oriented songs , but I believe when he composes or arranges for other artists it is his own work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What you are giving a link to is based on Shadmehr's own declaration of him composing the songs, and record shows that his own declarations are not much to count on.

 

So you mean , for example, even Mahasti's album (Az Khoda Khasteh) was not composed by Shadmehr himself?!! lol cmon man! i'll give u $1000 for any song that is a "rip off" on that album. I guess Shadmehr uses greek songs when it comes to his own work (as he has said himself, he likes greek and irish melodies) - btw, i dont support the fact that he declares himself as the composer of those greek-oriented songs , but I believe when he composes or arranges for other artists it is his own work.

 

Well, you are welcome to think and react as you wish, after all he has ripped off Siavash Ghomayshi and thereby his conduct is not exclusive to solely Greek or foreign music! my reaction however is based on how things progress! And the way I see it he hasn't done a thing to improve his reputation, on the contrary, it just gets worse when he blatantly continues! To me it just justifies the raised question even more!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well, you are welcome to think and react as you wish, after all he has ripped off Siavash Ghomayshi and thereby his conduct is not exclusive to solely Greek or foreign music!

 

well, of course we are all welcome to think as we wish, my friend(and im thinking logically here!)! Regarding the song "Paaeez" ... I dont think Shadmehr could mention Siavash's name on the album cover, because he would not get permission (from "ERSHAAD") , since the album was released in iran . I dont have Dehati's cover at hand for the moment, but I remeber that a section on the chart (where the composer, arranger, etc are listed) corresponding to that song was left blank - i guess it was for the lyrics, if not the composer ( Since siavash ghomayshi didnt even officially release an album with that song, theres barely enough information about lyricist or any others deserving credits for that song ). so... i cant really comment about whether shadmehr actually wanted to declare siavash's work as his own, or he was just worried about not getting permission for mentioning the name of an LA-based artist on the cover (!)

 

Btw, the arrangement is totally different in Shadmehr's version (not mentioning a slightly altered melody) - i.e. mentioning his own name as the arranger is justified in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:eek_wft: OMG, Aman az dasteh in dokhtareh Irooni keh ta yek dokhtareh hot mesleh bita miyad toe market uncomfortable mishand (Albateh adam hesabi va tahsil kardeh ba self confidence ham ziyad peyda misheh). Dar har soorat myspaceh bita jan por az commentayeh Irooni va positive hast keh kheili ghabeleh tahsin hast keh iroonihayeh ba energy mosbat va bazogh va saleegheh modern ham peyda misheh. Dar moredeh youtube, man khodam videohayeh bita joon ro negah kardam va ham toosh comentayeh mosbat didam va ham manfi keh bazam jayeh tahsin hast keh mardomeh azizeh ma vaghteshoon ro mizarand va comment midand.. Marketeh ma ehtiyaj dareh ingooneh artistayeh sexy ro ba good vacal dashteh basheh. Be nazareh bandeh, Bita ham sedayeh khoobi dareh, ham andameh ziba, ham soorateh nazi (man dar zemn ba aghideyeh shoma movafegh nistam keh hameyeh artistayeh jadideh dokhtar khoob nistand, ma faghat nabayad stylayeh madarbozorgi dar market dashteh bashim. Man fekr mikonam in masaleh be morooreh zaman ja miyofteh va bazi dokhtarayeh ma bejayeh inkeh yek nafaro keh workout mikoneh va heikaleh khoobi dareh attack konand, khodeshoo shooro be varzesh kardan mikonand. (vali faramoosh nasheh keh dokhtarayeh irooni kheili khoshkel va khoshandam hastand faghat baziyashoon, kheili roo dokhtarayeh khoshkeleh digeh hassasand) Onam hal khahad shod. (moshkeli nist)

Dar har soorat in nazareh man hast(man be shakhseh imagehayeh modern va sexy ro doost daram) dar eyneh hal be nazareh shoma ham ehteram mizaram. Be nazareh man artistayeh jadidi keh toe market omandand bekhosoos dokhtara kheili hameh motefavet va khoob hastand va agar shoma doost nadarid lotfan, be khanandehayeh ghadimi gosh bedid va bezarid maha lezateh in jadida ro bebarim.

Ba sepaseh faravan

PS: Tashakor az Admineh in site keh warning midand be afradi keh khosoomateh shakhsi be artistashoon darand (beh har dalili) va cherto pert minevisnad. Enteghadeh khoob sazandeh hast vali zamani keh hesaadat va khosoomateh shakhsi varedeh kar misheh digeh nazareh oon shakhs ghabeleh ehteram nist)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
:eek_wft: OMG, Aman az dasteh in dokhtareh Irooni keh ta yek dokhtareh hot mesleh bita miyad toe market uncomfortable mishand (Albateh adam hesabi va tahsil kardeh ba self confidence ham ziyad peyda misheh). Dar har soorat myspaceh bita jan por az commentayeh Irooni va positive hast keh kheili ghabeleh tahsin hast keh iroonihayeh ba energy mosbat va bazogh va saleegheh modern ham peyda misheh. Dar moredeh youtube, man khodam videohayeh bita joon ro negah kardam va ham toosh comentayeh mosbat didam va ham manfi keh bazam jayeh tahsin hast keh mardomeh azizeh ma vaghteshoon ro mizarand va comment midand.. Marketeh ma ehtiyaj dareh ingooneh artistayeh sexy ro ba good vacal dashteh basheh. Be nazareh bandeh, Bita ham sedayeh khoobi dareh, ham andameh ziba, ham soorateh nazi (man dar zemn ba aghideyeh shoma movafegh nistam keh hameyeh artistayeh jadideh dokhtar khoob nistand, ma faghat nabayad stylayeh madarbozorgi dar market dashteh bashim. Man fekr mikonam in masaleh be morooreh zaman ja miyofteh va bazi dokhtarayeh ma bejayeh inkeh yek nafaro keh workout mikoneh va heikaleh khoobi dareh attack konand, khodeshoo shooro be varzesh kardan mikonand. (vali faramoosh nasheh keh dokhtarayeh irooni kheili khoshkel va khoshandam hastand faghat baziyashoon, kheili roo dokhtarayeh khoshkeleh digeh hassasand) Onam hal khahad shod. (moshkeli nist)

Dar har soorat in nazareh man hast(man be shakhseh imagehayeh modern va sexy ro doost daram) dar eyneh hal be nazareh shoma ham ehteram mizaram. Be nazareh man artistayeh jadidi keh toe market omandand bekhosoos dokhtara kheili hameh motefavet va khoob hastand va agar shoma doost nadarid lotfan, be khanandehayeh ghadimi gosh bedid va bezarid maha lezateh in jadida ro bebarim.

Ba sepaseh faravan

PS: Tashakor az Admineh in site keh warning midand be afradi keh khosoomateh shakhsi be artistashoon darand (beh har dalili) va cherto pert minevisnad. Enteghadeh khoob sazandeh hast vali zamani keh hesaadat va khosoomateh shakhsi varedeh kar misheh digeh nazareh oon shakhs ghabeleh ehteram nist)

 

Azizam, mah doktaryayeh Iroonie maroof hasteem doreh donya barayeh class vah barayeh zeeba boodanehmoon. Mah heechvact nagofteen keh Bita joon zeshteh yah azash hasood hastim. Mah doktarhayeh Iranie alan niyaz dareem beh doktarhayeh javoon keh khosh seda hastan vah kosh andam, man digeh khasteh shodam az khanadehayeh ghadeemie. Vali, doktarhayeh mesleh Bita (vah albateh Sepideh hamintor) abroo vah classeh doktarhayeh Iraniehara meebaran, vah dorost matra nemekonan. Khanandeh boodan een neest keh lebas adam kam bepoosheh keh mardoom began keh chaghadre andameshoon koobeh, pas mah ghabool meekoneem keh khanadehhastan. Bita vah albateh Sepideh bayat olgoo payda konan vah bebeenan meekhan chee beh musceh keshvarehmoon ezaveh konan. Badaneh lokteshoon beh music cheezie ezafeh nemeekoneh, vah musiceshoon aslan rooyeh del nemeesheeneh. Aghalan, Sepideh bah teameh ghavie tar kar meekoneh, vah qualityeh karesh behtareh, vali Bita rooyeh qualityeh musikesh hata bayad kar koneh. Hichvact yavashborotolabash, nagoo keh mah hasood hasteem, hasood az chee? Araba az Bita classy tar meegardan vah meekhoonan!! Mah kaseero matra vah maroof nemeekoneem vah respect nemeekoneem keh natooneh dorost OLGOOYEH mah bashe!!!

PS: If this is Bita's friend, and not Bita, please be a "friend" and relay the message back to her!! And if anyone knows Sepideh, please do the same!! Classy Persian girls rock!!! :clap2:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OMG in yaroo baz oumad too labash :))

baba joon,why on earth should be be jealous of BITA??!! r u kiddin me?? be jahanam ke workout mikone.che rabti be VARZESH dare.u dont even make sense.az key tahala khanande bayad varzesh kone ta khoob bashe? bita to me is slightly better than shaghayegh in singing and shaghayegh is better looking than bita.so there u go.no one is jealous.but the thing is she's trying so hard to prove that she's sexy AND that she can sing.sorry but i dont think she's been successful in either one. come on! those outfits make her look like a pornstar.and im NOT being jealous im just being honest.so stop saying that to each and everyone who says something negative about your bita joon.what is wrong with u? if you are bita then i must say u're too desperate to get famous.if u're her friend tell her ppl prefer *a madarbozorg who can sing* over *a pornstar looking confused girl who works out everyday and who cant sing* in fact i think she needs to stop working out...or go to a LADIES gym for she looks like a man to me (too muscular) however thats just my opiniong and others might find her sexy.afterall i AM a girl.so no comments on the "bita har rooz varzesh mikone va khosh heykale" part.because that could as well be your personal opinion and dont expect everyone to agree with u on that...hala age fahmiiiiid!!!!

 

and stop acting like u're just her FAN! omg...i think u're either bita herself or someone who is in touch with her like everyday.if not,how the hell would u know that bita works out everyday??? do u go to the gym together?? or do u think ppl are THAT stupid hun?

 

i suggest u stop making a fool of yourself and either dont come here JUST TO TALK ABOUT BITA, or watch what u're saying cuz u sound like u need serious help. i wonder how much bita pays u to go around different websites and DEFEND her in the worst possible way.

 

darzemn.i,myself enjoy listening to older persian female singers and u calling them madarbozorg is an insult.so watch what u're saying.khodet har chi mikhay be hame migi va tavagho dari be bita joonet ke 2 rooze khanande shode kasi EHTERAM bezare.dar soorati ke ehterame kasi ro negah nemidari va fekr mikoni asemoon vaa shode o bita azash oftade paeen.

 

badesham,tipo in chiza has little to do with a singer's LONG TERM success.if u rely on your looks then u might be in the market for like 3-4 years and then u'll be gone.look at leila,her style is not the greatest but she has contributed so much to our music and yes,i enjoy listening to her songs and even watching her videos even if she is a MADARBOZORG to u now. or some others like Hayede n Mahasti (RIP).

 

i would love to see another young girl who dresses better than bita, someone who saves herself some dignity and class and doesnt go on every single website to promote herself. and no i wont be calling her MADARBOZORG just because she doesnt dress like ...THAT.

 

so deal with it.ppl have different tastes when it comes to music.u might not like mamanbozorgs and love bita.vali hame mesle to nistan pas boro bita goosh kon va inghadr ham zoor nagoo.to mikhay beri too khooneye mardom bebini raje be bita age kasi harf zad begiri bokoshish?seriously,or do u wanna force ppl to listen to her songs everyday?

 

bekhoda kheili khande daari.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
remeber that a section on the chart (where the composer, arranger, etc are listed) corresponding to that song was left blank

that's true.i remember that

 

Btw, the arrangement is totally different in Shadmehr's version (not mentioning a slightly altered melody)

 

mhm

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok ladies,

First off no need to get all jumpy and overly sensitive over something so simple!

All artists regardless of their nationality must always prepare themselves for the most vicious attacks and accusations of all kinds, however if the artist cannot take the criticism and negative comments of the audience then she/he definitely needs to consider her/his career, cuz entertainment is one of the most ruthless businesses one can get himself/herself involved in! someone here complained about Iroonis whining about female singers, this person even went over board accusing the critics of being 'Jealous' Astaghforellah!

 

Araba az Bita classy tar meegardan vah meekhoonan!!

 

Sarbehava87!

Here in Bia2 our tolerance on racism issues is zero, that means next time you make such comments I you will see a much harsher reaction from us!

 

Neeloofar!

You also need to tone down a bit, and think about what you wanna say before your emotions take over your courtesy and manners. Don't quickly react out of frustration, you're a good girl and I mean you mean no harm, but again your replies on such similar topics sound more like paranoia!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kheili jaleb hast keh sarbehava87 joined bia2 on Jan 04 08 and her first comment was on Bita :clap2: ... Very interesting and obvious what is going on here..

 

Neelofareh aziz keh mashalla kheili az hameyeh donya shaki hasti, Toe agar ro khanandehayeh javaneh zan hassas naboodi, inghadar bar nemigashti va hameja daem comentayeh cherto pert mineveshti va admin modam behet warning bedeh. Agar roo in kar hassas nisti chera nemiri khanandehayeh pooshideh va old fashionet ro donbal koni why do you care what is going on with the new comers with sexy styles :clap2: Man ham Faneh Bita hastam Ham sepideh ham beghiyeh khanandehayeh javaneh moderneh Irooni. Ham sedayeh Bita jan ro dost daram ham sedayeh sepideh jan va agar shoma ba styleh artistayee mesleh in azizan moshkel darid hamintor keh goftam nazaretoon ghabeleh ehteram hast ama ejazeh bedid maha keh doost darim, lezzatesho bebarim choon saleegheyeh maha kheili ba ham motefavet hast.. Potentialeh sedayeh in artisteh aziz "bita" bar hesabeh range va controleh seda va Ornomentayee keh estefadeh mikoneh kheili ziyad hast. Sedayeh bita technically kheili taeleem shodeh hast va motmaennan, kasayee keh dar music marketeh ma savadeh music ro be nahveh ahsand dashteh bashand in ro dark mikonand. Hamintor sedayeh sepideyeh aziz. In harfayee keh shoma mizanid mosalaman khosoomateh shakhsi va masaeleh darooniyeh shomast (pretty much har ja keh dar youtube, radio javan, bia2,... negah mikoni kasi keh hameja shar bepa kardeh barayeh artistayeh zan user nameh shomast va jalibish injast keh shoma daeman tekrar mikonid keh "ma dokhtara" jalebeh.. :brows:

Yek Entertainer bayad dar kenareh seda va tahsilat va shakhsiyateh ejtemayee, image va styleh jadid ro be market biyareh, Pas seda tanha kafi nist... albateh shoma keh goftid in barayeh shoma mohem nist vali trust me you can be one of the fewest in the market think like that.. Motmaenam kheili ha ba shoma kamelan mokhalef hastand az jomleh shahbaleh shabpareyeh aziz keh hamisheh donbaleh khanandeh ba image va styleh unique migardeh. Hamintor Sepideh jan ro peyda kard va Damesh Garm!!

Dar moredeh inkhe farmoodid man az koja midoonam keh bita jan workout mikoneh, I dont think it is a rocket sceince to figure this out :harhar_wft[1]: trust me har Kasi ba minimum knowlege inro khahad donest, choon chizi keh Ayan hast cheh Hajat be Bayan hast!.. Common!! Pas ziyad shooloogh poolooghesh nakonid. Man az neveshtaneh toe in site lezat mibaram va az shoma tashakkor mikonam keh response be javabayeh man midid.. khahesh mikonam keh frustrate nashid va ba calm voice argument konid :dance_baby_wft: LIFE IS SHORT ENJOY IT.

Dar zemn shoma frmoodid keh mano hire kardand :dance_baby_wft: oonam jalebeh choon man barax fekr kardam shoma hire shodid keh moratab cherto pert barayeh in artista benevisid :brows:

Digar Arzi nadaram. Moteshakeram az vaghteh shoma.

Zende Bad Iran Va Irani va Mashalla be Dokhtarayeh Irooni keh dar donya TAK hastand!!!

Neelofareh aziz, shomaro ham be onvaneh yek HAMVATAN doost daram. Be omideh roozi keh ma Irooni ha yad begirim be nazariyateh hamdigeh ehteram begozarim va eshkal va eradamoon ro ba ehteram va calm tone be gosheh yek digar beresoonim.

PS: Ba Ehterameh ziyad be modiraneh siteh bia2.com keh in ejaza ro be ma midand keh ba ham goftegooyee dashteh bashim.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Alright, here is the deal! If you guys want to continue discussing this or any other matter you MUST STOP labelling each other or accusing each other of nonsense! You don't have to agree on things, like many others who discuss here! Still keep it civil and constructive! What we're seeing here is starting to get nasty, one critique/defence of the singer and one provoking comment to the person who does it, and so it goes on and on! Either agree on to disagree or continue without commenting each other or the next post who keeps on this tendency to personal attacks will lead to suspension!

 

Tone it down and focus on the subject, leave "each other" out of the equation!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ok im seriously tired of these pointless discussions. PLZ BASSE DIGE!! lol

faghat ye chiz migam chon nemitoonam bebinam too ye public form kasi behem intori tohmat mizane ke dare bishtar shabihe personal grudge mishe...ino migam and i wont reply to any of "yavashboro..." posts anymore

 

FOR THE LAST TIME:

man na roo youtube va na jaye dige naraftam bad begam az hameye artist haye irani.i swear i didnt.and if u believe in karma then stop accusing me bc it wont do any good to bita JAN's career.

 

oh and just to clearify things, SARBEHAVA is NOT me and if anyone has any doubts let bia2 prove that to u.(in case ke kasi hamchin fekri karde!)

hamoontor ke bazia faghat 7 ta post daran ke hamash raje be bita boode khob sarbehava ham labod oumade ke javab bede!!

 

in topic ham baraye "comments on new iranian releases" hast, na "defending new female artists and attacking those who dont love them"!!

bita's was a new artist and her album was a new release so its natural if ppl talk about her in here.so i dont understand why someone should attack others for simply saying what they think of some artist and her album.

 

"ba tashakor az admine haye bia2 ke mizaran man ino post konam" (these seem to be some magic words,baes mishe har chi begi kasi behet na warning bede na notice kone ke chi gofti)...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Alright, here is the deal! If you guys want to continue discussing this or any other matter you MUST STOP labelling each other or accusing each other of nonsense! You don't have to agree on things, like many others who discuss here! Still keep it civil and constructive! What we're seeing here is starting to get nasty, one critique/defence of the singer and one provoking comment to the person who does it, and so it goes on and on! Either agree on to disagree or continue without commenting each other or the next post who keeps on this tendency to personal attacks will lead to suspension!

 

Tone it down and focus on the subject, leave "each other" out of the equation!

 

sorry i had to say these again cuz im tired of getting accused of "commenting on all female artists' videos" or "trashtalking behind all artists" or "hating female artists" cuz thats just not true.

taghsire man shod ke aslan javab dadam az aval.agar javab nemidadam nemiraft dastan sare ham kone ke "u're all over youtube"...koja?where on youtube?what is she talking about?hame midonan who is all over internet to start discussion like THIS which at the end,gets like what you said, NASTY. so i appreciate if "yavashboro..." drops it and doesnt bring it up again. vali lotfan monsefane begoo ki shoroo kard aval!! who came out of nowhever and started attacking me? man aslan chize badi ham nagofte boodam az avalesh.montaha bazia darejeye tahamoleshoon paeene fory jigho vigh mikonan.be man migofti vaghti kasi raje ba andy chizi mige man tollerate konam va attack nakonamo....hala its the same situation.taze ino ke khodet ham didi ghablan email dade boode ke raje be bita harf nazanin.pas ishoon ham bayad tahamol dashte bashe va ye rooz dar mioon inja raje be bita essay nanevise va too oun essay hey gir be man nade.akhe man chikar konam ke ki too youtube ya folan site chi gofte be bita.why should I get attacked?aslan why attacking? kasi behesh nagoft ke "tone down" kone vali be nazare man age khodesh az aval tone down mikard aslan inghadr kesh nemioomad ke.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i just listened to leila's new album. nemidoonam chera vali be nazaram aslan styele leila nabood.the music n lyric n everything was good vali ouna ro bayad yeki dige mikhoond engar.i miss her early 90's music. but i dont know...it might grow on me as i listen to it more n more.now i know how some ppl felt after listening to andy's recent albums.so i hope i end up liking each n every track!

 

i think ramin zamani's style is too "modern" for leila,and leila is one of those singers who shouldnt switch to "modern" like that. nemidoonam in album hit track dare aslan?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"ba tashakor az admine haye bia2 ke mizaran man ino post konam" (these seem to be some magic words,baes mishe har chi begi kasi behet na warning bede na notice kone ke chi gofti)...

 

 

Alright, here is the deal! If you guys want to continue discussing this or any other matter you MUST STOP labelling each other or accusing each other of nonsense! You don't have to agree on things, like many others who discuss here! Still keep it civil and constructive! What we're seeing here is starting to get nasty, one critique/defence of the singer and one provoking comment to the person who does it, and so it goes on and on! Either agree on to disagree or continue without commenting each other or the next post who keeps on this tendency to personal attacks will lead to suspension!

 

Tone it down and focus on the subject, leave "each other" out of the equation!

 

sorry i had to say these again cuz im tired of getting accused of "commenting on all female artists' videos" or "trashtalking behind all artists" or "hating female artists" cuz thats just not true.

taghsire man shod ke aslan javab dadam az aval.agar javab nemidadam nemiraft dastan sare ham kone ke "u're all over youtube"...koja?where on youtube?what is she talking about?hame midonan who is all over internet to start discussion like THIS which at the end,gets like what you said, NASTY. so i appreciate if "yavashboro..." drops it and doesnt bring it up again. vali lotfan monsefane begoo ki shoroo kard aval!! who came out of nowhever and started attacking me? man aslan chize badi ham nagofte boodam az avalesh.montaha bazia darejeye tahamoleshoon paeene fory jigho vigh mikonan.be man migofti vaghti kasi raje ba andy chizi mige man tollerate konam va attack nakonamo....hala its the same situation.taze ino ke khodet ham didi ghablan email dade boode ke raje be bita harf nazanin.pas ishoon ham bayad tahamol dashte bashe va ye rooz dar mioon inja raje be bita essay nanevise va too oun essay hey gir be man nade.akhe man chikar konam ke ki too youtube ya folan site chi gofte be bita.why should I get attacked?aslan why attacking? kasi behesh nagoft ke "tone down" kone vali be nazare man age khodesh az aval tone down mikard aslan inghadr kesh nemioomad ke.

 

 

When we urge the members to something then we MEAN IT! What part of my comment was unclear? No matter who had started this it was supposed to END after my post! I did not warn or ban any of you and I didn't asked for a recap! We see clearly who is doing what! All three of you use the same approach and jargon! I said no more commenting each other! but like before you cant curb yourself! The next post of the same type would lead to suspension and yours was next in addition to that you've been warned before! Suspended from the forum in 14 days, and this is my shortest ever given! I just want you to understand how a forum works! Again, reconsider before you put your thoughts in words and I'm sure since you don't mean much of the stuff said it wont be repeated!

 

Again, I don't want to see such approach in the forum again! Neither want I people dragging it out by "explaining"! End of the discussion!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW...that was BY FAR the most immature conversation/debate/shitfest I've heard/read in a LONNNNG time. If you don't like someone's music and/or how they promote it, then don't listen to them. Simple as that.

 

Personally, I have little problem with whatever Bita's doing. If she wants to dress in skimpy cloths, then LET HER. Christ, have any of you ever been to LA? Half the Iranian girls I've met in Cali dress and look JUST like her. It's not like she's reinventing the wheel or corrupting the youth or anything; She has a nice body, so why not let her flash it? Sex sells in music, no matter the industry. You guys may not say it aloud, but you all know it's true.

 

Now about her music:...Her voice CLEARLY isn't very strong, but her music is kinda catchy (if you listen to it more than once..it takes a bit of time to adjust to it because the sound is kind of new in the Persian music scene). NO DOUBT her sex appeal has a lot to do with why she's in the industry now. If she were less attractive (not saying she's a supermodel, but she's pretty) then I DOUBT she would have much success because her voice is kind of weak. It's not that her voice is bad, but it's kind of average. Nothing special. But the reason why she will probably have some success is because of her looks. For example, look at Shaghayegh. Her voice honestly sucked, but her album was on top of the charts for a while. Now, why was that....? haha So, this is proof that sex sells in the Persian music industry, despite what the critics may claim.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WOW...that was BY FAR the most immature conversation/debate/shitfest I've heard/read in a LONNNNG time. If you don't like someone's music and/or how they promote it, then don't listen to them. Simple as that.

 

I think this is the most flawed argument anyone has ever made. I'll make it short and simple for you. I see, I like, I praise OR I see, I dislike, I blaze! So whether you or anyone else likes it or not I for ONE will have my say, make my mark and shout out loud about it. Whether in politics, music, society, whatever.

 

Personally, I have little problem with whatever Bita's doing. If she wants to dress in skimpy cloths, then LET HER. Christ, have any of you ever been to LA? Half the Iranian girls I've met in Cali dress and look JUST like her. It's not like she's reinventing the wheel or corrupting the youth or anything; She has a nice body, so why not let her flash it? Sex sells in music, no matter the industry. You guys may not say it aloud, but you all know it's true.

 

A lot of things sell in this world my economy lecturer once said there is a market for just about EVERYTHING but what stops us is our morals and conscience. Shall we all set up a Class A drugs company for money? That's shallow buddy.

 

BTW 2 'wrongs' don't make a 'right'! Just to clear that up for you. Don't ever try to justify one persons ridiculous actions by another persons absurd actions.

 

Now about her music:...Her voice CLEARLY isn't very strong, but her music is kinda catchy (if you listen to it more than once..it takes a bit of time to adjust to it because the sound is kind of new in the Persian music scene). NO DOUBT her sex appeal has a lot to do with why she's in the industry now. If she were less attractive (not saying she's a supermodel, but she's pretty) then I DOUBT she would have much success because her voice is kind of weak. It's not that her voice is bad, but it's kind of average. Nothing special. But the reason why she will probably have some success is because of her looks. For example, look at Shaghayegh. Her voice honestly sucked, but her album was on top of the charts for a while. Now, why was that....? haha So, this is proof that sex sells in the Persian music industry, despite what the critics may claim.

 

As Keano once wisely pointed out in this forum several times- sex sells but only temporarily so sooner or later people will tune out of Bita and she can join the other failed Iranian singers or 'artists', if you insist on using that term to describe them lol. I mean I doubt people will watch her to get seduced though this is just my assumption LOL!

 

Besides, we (the not so impressed audience) are not telling her not to exist we want her to succeed and be a positive contributer to the Iranian industry and therefore society hence we criticise. Only time will tell whether she will be a legend until then au revoir lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×